How to calculate profit on a watch sale
Profit per watch, step by step. Margin scheme vs standard VAT, service and commission costs, margin % and ROI, with one worked example in euros.

Contentstap to expand
Short answer: profit on a watch is the selling price, minus the VAT you owe on that sale, minus what you paid for the watch, minus every cost you put into it (service, polishing, shipping, commission). The step most dealers get wrong is the VAT: under the margin scheme it is worked out on the margin only, under the standard rate on the whole price. The same watch at the same price can earn several times more or less depending on how it was bought.
The four lines
For one sale, write down:
- Selling price. What the buyer pays, gross.
- VAT on this sale. Depends on the tax treatment (below).
- Buying price. What you paid, net of any input VAT you reclaim.
- Costs on the watch. Service, parts, polishing, shipping, a strap, commission paid to a broker or platform. Every cost that belongs to this piece. Buying price plus these costs is the landed cost.
Profit = selling price − VAT − buying price − costs.
The VAT line decides most of it
Margin scheme (§ 25a UStG). For a watch you bought from a private seller or another margin-scheme seller. The VAT is contained in the margin, the selling price minus the buying price. At 19 %, that is 19/119 of the margin. Your costs do not reduce the margin the VAT is worked out on; they reduce your profit. If you sell at a loss, there is no margin VAT.
Standard rate. For a watch you bought with VAT and reclaimed it. The VAT is contained in the whole selling price: 19/119 of the gross price at 19 %.
Tax-exempt sales. An intra-community supply to an EU business or an export outside the EU can be tax exempt, with conditions. See selling a watch to another EU country and exporting a watch outside the EU.
Which treatment applies is a tax question. Agree it with your tax advisor; what follows is arithmetic.
A worked example
Example figures, at the German standard rate of 19%. You buy a watch for €7,400, spend €380 on a service and pay a €250 commission to the broker who brought the buyer. Total costs on the watch: €630. You sell it for €9,900.
Margin scheme (bought from a private seller):
- Margin: 9,900 − 7,400 = €2,500
- VAT in the margin: 2,500 × 19/119 = €399.16
- Profit: 2,500 − 399.16 − 630 = €1,470.84
Standard rate (bought from a dealer with VAT, €7,400 net after reclaiming it):
- VAT in the price: 9,900 × 19/119 = €1,580.67
- Profit: 9,900 − 1,580.67 − 7,400 − 630 = €289.33
Export, tax exempt (sold to a buyer outside the EU, conditions met):
- VAT: €0
- Profit: 9,900 − 7,400 − 630 = €1,870.00
Same watch, same price, three different results. Under the margin scheme, the VAT is 19/119 of €2,500. Under the standard rate, it is 19/119 of €9,900. To earn the same €1,470.84 under the standard rate, you would have to sell for about €11,306.
This is why the tax treatment belongs to the watch from the day you buy it. It changes the price you can pay. See how to price a pre-owned watch.
Margin %, ROI and days
Three numbers put a profit into context:
- Margin % = profit ÷ net revenue (selling price minus VAT). In the margin scheme example: 1,470.84 ÷ 9,500.84 = about 15.5 %.
- ROI = profit ÷ (buying price + costs). Here: 1,470.84 ÷ 8,030 = about 18.3 %. This is what the money you tied up earned.
- Days in stock. €1,470 in 20 days and €1,470 in 200 days are different businesses. See aged watch inventory.
Where profit quietly disappears
- Costs on a separate sheet. A service invoice that is not on the watch makes every report look better than your bank account.
- Commission counted twice, or never. A commission is a cost on the watch. Book it once.
- Gross and net mixed. A buying price with VAT you reclaimed is not your cost. Your cost is the net amount.
- Returns. A watch that comes back is a reversed sale, not a deleted one. See cancelling an invoice.
How ChronoDesk calculates it
Every watch in ChronoDesk carries its buying price, the tax scheme chosen at purchase and its additional costs as separate lines with a type (service, repair, shipping, box, commission, other) and an optional receipt. A commission on a consignment sale is booked as a commission cost. The margin comes from the purchase price, every extra cost and the sale price.
Statistics then show profit by month, brand and channel, days in stock in brackets, and capital tied up by brand with the watches behind each.
FAQ
Does a service lower the VAT under the margin scheme?
No. Under § 25a the VAT is worked out on the selling price minus the buying price. A service you paid for lowers your profit, not that margin. Ask your tax advisor about the details for your case.
Should margin % be on gross or net revenue?
Net revenue, with the VAT taken out. Otherwise a standard-rate sale looks more profitable than it is.
Is commission part of the buying price?
Treat it as a cost on the watch. It belongs to this piece and lowers its profit, whichever channel charged it.
ChronoDesk is free for 60 days. See the real profit of every watch you sell. See the plans.