Skip to content
Back to Journal
Guides5 November 2026

How to describe a watch's condition in a listing

Writing an honest, consistent condition description for a pre-owned watch. Grading scale, what to state, photos to take and wording that avoids disputes.

Viktor Siewert
Viktor Siewert
Founder, ChronoDesk
Contentstap to expand

Short answer: a good condition description has three parts: a grade from a fixed scale, a short list of what you actually checked (case, bracelet, crystal, dial, hands, movement function, service, polish, set), and photos that show every point you mention, flaws included. Say what you checked and what you found, not how the watch makes you feel. Use the same grade and the same words on every channel. That is what keeps a buyer from saying "this is not what you described".

Why condition is where disputes start

Price, reference and set are easy to agree on. Condition is not. "Very good" means one thing to a dealer who sees hundreds of watches and another to a buyer who has saved for this one. Most returns and complaints come down to a description that promised more than the photos showed, or photos that hid what the text left out.

Two rules prevent most of them:

  1. Describe, do not sell. State facts a buyer can check.
  2. Show what you say. Every flaw you mention has a photo, and every photo matches the text.

Use one grading scale

Pick a condition grading scale and use it for every watch, every listing and every channel. A practical scale with seven steps:

| Grade | Meaning in practice | |---|---| | New | Unworn, with stickers and all original packaging. See unworn. | | Like new | Worn very little, no visible marks without a loupe. | | Very good | Light signs of wear on close inspection, nothing that catches the eye at wrist distance. | | Good | Visible signs of wear on case and bracelet, crystal and dial clean. | | Used | Clear wear, small dents or scratches, everything works. | | Fair | Heavy wear or a known flaw, priced accordingly. | | Incomplete | Missing parts or not working, sold as such. |

Write the meaning of your scale down once, for example on your website or in your listing template, and stick to it. A grade is only useful if it means the same thing every time.

What to state

Go through the watch in a fixed order. The same order every time makes it harder to forget something.

  • Case. Scratches, dents, wear on edges and lugs. Say whether the case has been polished or appears unpolished, and how you know (sharp bevels, original finish). If you do not know, say so.
  • Bezel. Marks, fading, inserts, rotation. See bezel.
  • Bracelet or strap. Stretch, number of links, whether it is original, wear on the clasp.
  • Crystal. Scratches, chips. See crystal.
  • Dial and hands. Spots, patina, lume condition, whether the dial is original or a service dial. See dial and hands.
  • Movement function. Does it run, wind and set correctly? Do the date, chronograph and other functions work? If you checked the rate on a timegrapher, give the result and the date of the test.
  • Water resistance. Only state it if you tested it. See pressure test.
  • Service. Last service with date and who did it, if documented. See service history.
  • Parts. Any non-original parts. See aftermarket parts.
  • Set. Exactly what comes with the watch: box, outer box, papers (dated or blank), tags, extra links, receipts. "Full set" only when everything is there. See box and papers.

Photos to take

A clear photo set for every watch:

  1. Dial straight on, in daylight or soft light, no reflections.
  2. Case from both sides, including the crown side.
  3. Case back.
  4. Lugs and bevels at an angle, to show polish or wear.
  5. Bracelet stretched and closed, and the clasp inside and out.
  6. Every flaw you mention, close up.
  7. The full set laid out.
  8. For your own records only: the serial number and the papers. Keep the serial out of public listings.

Photograph flaws in good light rather than hiding them. A buyer who finds a scratch you showed has no complaint; a buyer who finds one you did not show has a strong one.

Wording that avoids disputes

| Avoid | Write instead | |---|---| | "Perfect condition" | "No visible marks on case or crystal without a loupe" | | "Mint" | The grade from your scale, plus what you checked | | "Never polished" | "Sharp bevels, appears unpolished" or "polishing history unknown" | | "Runs perfectly" | "Runs and sets correctly; rate measured on [date]" | | "Recently serviced" | "Serviced in [month, year] by [watchmaker], invoice available" | | "Complete set" | The list of what is included | | "Waterproof" | "Pressure tested on [date]" or nothing |

Superlatives are not evidence. A specific statement you can back up protects you; a vague one invites a claim.

Keep it the same on every channel

A watch listed on your own website, on Chrono24, on Shopify and in a WhatsApp group should carry the same grade, the same set and the same flaws. Differences between channels are what a careful buyer finds first. Write the description once, in your own system, and let every channel take it from there. See multi-channel watch listing.

How ChronoDesk helps

  • Condition on the watch record on a fixed scale: new, like new, very good, good, used, fair, incomplete. See inventory.
  • Scope of delivery (watch only, box only, papers only, full set) plus a free-text note for details such as tags or extra links.
  • Photos: a main photo and a gallery per watch.
  • One record for every channel. The same watch record feeds the Chrono24 feed, Shopify and marketplace listings, so condition and set come from one entry everywhere (mapped to Chrono24's own condition scale in its feed). The serial number stays private and never appears in listings or feeds. See syncing.
  • Handover protocol PDF with the condition, the set and condition notes, signed at handover.
  • History on each watch, showing old and new values when a field changes.

FAQ

Should I say a watch has been polished?

Yes, if you know. If you are not sure, say the polishing history is unknown and show the lugs and bevels in the photos. Do not claim "unpolished" without good reason.

How detailed does a condition description need to be?

Detailed enough that a buyer would not be surprised when they open the box. Cover case, bracelet, crystal, dial, function, service and set, and show every flaw.

Can I use different descriptions on different platforms?

You can shorten the text for a platform, but keep the grade, the set and the flaws identical. Different statements about the same watch are an easy target in a dispute.

What if I did not test something?

Say so. "Not pressure tested" or "functions checked, rate not measured" is honest and gives the buyer a fair picture.

ChronoDesk is free for 60 days. See the plans.

Last updated on 5 November 2026. General information reflecting ChronoDesk’s understanding at the time of publication, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules differ by country and change over time, so have your tax advisor or lawyer confirm your own case before you act on it. See our disclaimer for the full notice.
Share
Tagsconditionlistinggradingphotossetdisputes