Differenzbesteuerung
German margin VAT scheme under § 25a UStG that taxes only the dealer's margin instead of the full sale price. Used when reselling used goods bought without VAT, for example from private sellers.
Differenzbesteuerung (the margin scheme) is a special VAT regime in § 25a of the German Umsatzsteuergesetz (UStG), based on the EU rules for second-hand goods. It applies to dealers who buy used goods without VAT being charged to them (for example from private individuals, from businesses under the small-business rule, or from other dealers who sold under the margin scheme) and resell them.
Under standard taxation (Regelbesteuerung), a dealer charges VAT on the full sale price. Under Differenzbesteuerung, VAT is calculated only on the margin (sale price minus purchase price). This page is general information; check your own cases with your tax advisor.
How the calculation works
Example (assumed figures): a watch bought from a private seller for 8,500 euros and sold for 9,500 euros has a margin of 1,000 euros. The margin contains the VAT: 1,000 / 1.19 = about 840 euros net margin and about 160 euros VAT. The dealer owes about 160 euros to the tax office.
Under standard taxation, the same sale at 9,500 euros gross would contain about 1,517 euros VAT, with no input VAT to deduct because the private seller charged none.
Invoice requirements
A § 25a invoice differs from a standard invoice in two ways. It must carry the note "Gebrauchtgegenstände / Sonderregelung" (or the equivalent wording for the goods concerned), and it must not show VAT separately. A business buyer cannot deduct input VAT from a § 25a invoice.
Common pitfalls
- Wrong source. The scheme only applies if no deductible VAT was charged on the purchase. A watch bought on a normal VAT invoice must be sold with standard VAT.
- Costs do not reduce the margin. Service, repair or shipping costs are not part of the purchase price for the margin calculation. Input VAT on those costs is generally deductible in the normal way.
- No offset of losses. The margin is calculated per item; a loss on one watch does not reduce the tax on another.
- Sales to other EU countries. The VAT exemption for intra-community supplies does not apply to § 25a sales; exports to third countries can still be exempt (see Ausfuhrlieferung).
- Records. Purchase price, sale price and margin must be recorded per item, which is where the Ankaufsrechnung comes in.
In ChronoDesk
The tax scheme is chosen when the watch is bought, and the sales invoice follows it: a § 25a invoice carries the required note and shows no VAT. Purchase price, every extra cost and sale price are kept per watch, so the margin is visible. For a dealer's view of the scheme, see Differenzbesteuerung for watch dealers.
FAQ
When can I use the margin scheme for a watch?
When you bought the watch without deductible VAT, for example from a private seller, from a small business that charged no VAT, or from a dealer who sold it under the margin scheme. Your tax advisor can confirm individual cases.
Does a margin-scheme invoice show VAT?
No. It carries the note "Gebrauchtgegenstände / Sonderregelung" and no separate VAT amount. A business buyer cannot deduct input VAT from it.
Do repair costs reduce the taxable margin?
No. Only the purchase price counts for the margin. Input VAT on repair and service bills is generally deductible in the normal way.
Related: ankaufsrechnung, margin, reverse-charge, innergemeinschaftliche-lieferung, zugferd.